Belles- Lettres

 India is a diverse country that emphasises on secularism but the nation still encounters with various communal violence and religious conflicts. Vikal Kumar was a popular Hindi poet who expressed the substandard state of the oppressed and marginalized society in his poetry. One of his poems, 'Can you make out' reveals the brutality of communal riots through a series of rhetorical questions. He argues whether anyone can recognise the community or religion of the people whose blood is being shed in a futile fight. The answer is definitely 'no'. He stresses that it is all about being humane and not about being a Hindi or a Muslim. The title of the poem too, holds immense significance as the bitter truth is that India has not yet discovered a solution to the problem of escaping this rampage. It is quite unfortunate to accept the reality that these riots doesn't seem like it is leaving the premises of the nation any time soon. Respecting every citizens' caste, creed

 The poem 'Can You Make Out 'by Kumar vikal unleashes  a storm of protest against centuries old but still persisting communal riots in India. Throughout its flow the Poem addresses the issue without losing its genuinity.It is written in the form of questions raised towards the humanity and the conclusion is trying to answer them. The questions that Kumar Vikal advocates is of real significance ,as the title Indicates Can you identify the religion of a person by the smell of his blood Splattered on the road.The answer here is pretty sure is a big 'No',because the riots and rebellions only last upto the death of a huge innocent public.As the poet admits here, the rebellious society that includes each one of us cannot answer for the tears of a mother . We cannot wipe them with the aid of sympathy but what we are able Of is to break the silence of centuries .Therefore, all together the poem is a bunch of questions answered with incomplete thoughts and a gentle reminder to t

The poem by Kumar Vikal, titled “Can you make out”, is a direct criticism on the communal atrocities committed in the name of religion, caste and beliefs and the effects these acts have on the people of the society at a large. The title itself is of the rhetorical kind, with the poet asking the readers if they are able to understand or decipher the meanings behind the various atrocities being described in the poem. The poem as a whole further explores the question raised by the titular question and attempts to provide suitable explanations for it but ultimately ends showing our inability to even attempt to justify some of the more heinous deeds and their consequences. The literary work holds a mirror up to society and its inability to understand that the only real sufferer in this pointless conflict is the common man, who in the race to find his daily bread and conquer his dream, happened to stand out in the eyes of his assailants.

Kumar Vikal was a famous Hindi Poet. Throughout his poems we could see his voice for marginalized oppressed societies. Can you make out is also tells us the same story of people who lost everything because of mad reckless riots which came from different entities. India is a land of diversities. And this unique feature of India could make India more proud and in the same time it could become a curse. Because each one of us has different entities such as caste, religion, believes,  culture, region and so on. It is really hard to maintain its inner peace. At times it will cost huge loss for our nation. The people don't know why they are fighting for. At last they are shedding their blood for these mere caste and other worthless stuffs. Then we cannot identify them by their caste or class.  We may be different according to our caste and religion but biologically we all are same - Homo sapiens. The person who set frontiers are none other than us. Until we break these shackles we cannot

The poem ‘Can You Make Out’ by Kumar Vikal is of enormous significance in the contemporary world. It is the reflection of hardships and depredations faced by many around the world and in India in the name of religion, caste, creed and culture. The title ‘Can You Make Out’ hints at the relevance of the issue and it points out that each individual should try to resolve the crisis and we should stand united despite the differences. It will make a huge impact on the society and thus it initiates the beginning of a better tomorrow. India is a country that is an amalgamation of several culture, religion, diversities and cuisines. India had witnessed a bloodletting partition seventy -five years ago as a consequence of rising tensions between different religious communities. Even after Independence we have a long way to go. Religious harmony is a concept that indicates there is love and affection between different religions. It is fundamental in the development of any country. However in the p

Can You Make Out by Kumar Vikal is a wonderfully crafted, heart touching and moving poem that reminds us to voice out the loud pertinent questions addressing Indian nationalism with its medley of people. The very title of the poem "Can you make out" arises the much-unspoken question that whether we could make out, to which caste, creed or religion the aftermath of these petty riots and outbreaks of  civil   violence belong.  It is truly saddening to see us making walls within ourselves, in the name of religion, caste and other fiddling differences when we all in core should be humans with humanity. In the occurrences of these instances, it should be us and our leaders, who should think and act sensibly when we all know that this hate and violence clearly ends up with pain, bloodshed and tears. Hence with the poet, it's high time we realize and respect our commonality as humans with the same blood in our veins than differentiating ourselves on the grounds of beliefs and id

The poet begins the poem with a list of questions, and the title also is a question, 'Can You Make Out'. The question is very relevant in our time and the answer should be the remedy for the troubles. He says we can not identify the caste of the blood by the smell. We can not see any creed in the shattered pieces of bread during a riot. We can not see a race or religion in the blood stained clothes after a calamity. But when we see the tears of a mother who is helpless and worries about the daughter who will never return, what will be our emotion and feeling. It will not be the thought of any caste or creed. Always we can see the victims are the common man who is struggling for their daily bread. We always see the pathetic reality of the wounded children who were suppose to be with their books and toys. At the end, the poet want us to light the lamp for peace. He want us not to see any religion in blood and tears. He blaims the meaningless, arguments of the society and u

The poem “Can you make out” by Kumar Vikal can be considered as an outcry against violence carried out in the name of religion and caste. The title is significant because the poem discusses about the situation where the blood lies splattered on the road and we are unable to identify whether the blood belongs to Hindu, Muslim, Sikh or Christian. What we know is, it belongs to a human. The poet portrays various instances to depict the atrocities of riots. The ordinary people are the one who is mostly affected by the riots. We may be able to console them but we couldn’t wipe their inner cries. They lose their loved ones and find it very difficult to recover from the aftermath of riots. The poet portray that the riots are creating destructions and pull the people down to poverty rather than sowing the seeds of peace.

The poem Can You Make out by Kumar Vikal brings into light the sufferings and misery of common people during any communal riot which are never addressed by anyone. The title itself seeks the meaning of the uproars caused in the name of different faiths. Throughout the poem,poet raises questions on distinguishing people based on their castes and religion. He asks if you can make out the religion of a person by the smell of his blood which is splattered on the road. He asks if you can make out the religion of a person by the smell of the food scattered on the ground. He further seeks the religion and the meaning of the tears of the mothers who are shattered by hearing the death of their children. Through the entire poem, the poet seeks the meaning of communal riots and violence caused by them. The title justifies the theme of the poem and makes the readers think about the effects of such riots and the importance of wiping the tears of the people who are affected by them. Whatever be the

India is a country having a highly complex social mosaic. Each person represents a particular ethnicity, religion and cast. This vast spread cultural diversity was not much chaotic and they blended into their respective positions. But it is not always possible for national unity and diversity to coexist. Kumar Vikal has pointed out this communal issues in his poem 'can you make out'. Here the poet is asking whether you can make out the religion or ethnicity of a person's blood or tears that they shed while being killed in these brutal riots. From the question that is raised in the title, we can discern that it is impossible. Because at the end of the day we are all humans with the same flesh and blood. The expressions such as broken cycles, scattered tiffin carrier and worn-out shoes represent the socially and economically disadvantaged people and not the powerful and wealthy ones. They are the victims of such communal massacres. Kumar Vikal reveals through his poem that

 The title 'Can you make out' by Kumar Vikal is very significant in today's context in India. Seeing the blood splattered on the road can you tell whose blood it is by smelling it? Is it the blood of a Hindu, a Muslim, a Sikh a Christian, a brother or sister.(It is not possible) There is a Tiffin-carrier half hidden among the stones that are scattered on the road. There is a sweet smell of bread coming from it. Can you tell to which caste the smell belongs? No. There are blood stained clothes, worn out shoes, broken cycles, books and toys. Can you tell to which nationality do they belong? The mother is waiting for her daughter from the school without knowing that she has been killed. Can you find out the creed of those tears flowing down from the mother? And do you know the inner meaning of the cries of the wounded that are in hospital? The author identifies the blood as that of the man whose tiff in- box emits the sweet smell of bread. The blood belongs to the caste of tho